Showing posts with label Bollywood. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bollywood. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Raavan or Raavanan: Film Review, July 2010




Toronto, Canada

Raavan or Raavanan – The Film Makes one Think

Raj S. Rangarajan

NEW YORK: When one thinks of a Bollywood film one normally associates it with escapism, with fun or fantasy or both. So, when the film Raavan (Hindi) or Raavanan (Tamil) came along, one was forced to wear one’s thinking cap and wonder what exactly was director Mani Ratnam trying to convey.
In a first-of-its-kind, live experience with the actors and maker of Raavan, thanks to Cisco technology’s TelePresence – media from New York, Mumbai, Chennai, Delhi and Dubai could see and hear clearly, in real-time, face-to-face interactions between participants: Director Mani Ratnam and Tamil actor Vikram in Chennai and Aishwarya Rai Bachchan and Abhishek Bachchan in Mumbai, thousands of miles away.

To a question Ratnam explained why he was not into sending messages to society at large. “I am not providing any message, I merely share an emotion, share a thought, share laughter, that’s what we do.” The director has stretched the 138-minute film a bit to live up to the title since the 14-year Ramayana analogy had to be adapted to 14 days for the movie. The allegory is clear. You have the forest, the intrigue, the 14 years, the name of the film, the locations and the usual connection between good and evil except that one is left wondering whether good really triumphs over evil or is it love that conquers.

Ratnam suggests, one should see Raavan or Raavanan from Ragini's (Aishwarya) point of view. (She plays the same role in both: Hindi and Tamil.) Wife of a police inspector, Ragini has clear views on right and wrong. In her journey there is the hunter and the hunted and with roles and characters constantly changing, one wonders if the hunted becomes the hunter. The battle between good and evil continues, and when the lines between them tend to blur one wonders whom to favor: the cops (Inspector Dev played by Prithviraj in Hindi and Vikram in Tamil) or a tribal chief Beera Munda (Abhishek in Hindi) or Veeraiya (Vikram in Tamil) who fancies Ragini.

Actor Govinda could have been used better in the Hindi version. He pops up suddenly (like Hanuman) specially when he has to help the inspector-husband, Dev, who sees himself as the law, the punisher and the righteous. The untamed but popular tribal leader kidnaps Ragini, (an epitome of conscience and beauty) to avenge abuse of his sister played by Priyamani (Jamuna in Hindi and Vennila in Tamil) by the inspector’s men. Aishwarya shows emotion in a few scenes and Abhishek's effort at emotional conflict is commendable.

Both, the Tamil and Hindi versions were above par though Vikram, the Tamil actor (as Dev) has performed better than Abhishek in the same role. Ratnam brushed aside Vikram’s initial hesitation about playing Dev in Hindi. Says Vikram, “The most difficult thing for me was the Hindi version, I didn’t want to do it, but “Mani-sir” said, “You can do it and boosted my confidence.” Added Vikram, “I found every location beautiful. Wherever we went, we had to drive down in a car for two hours, then get into a jeep for an hour and walk for another 15 minutes, and the beautiful sites [in North India and South India] were visual treats.” Overall, it’s a plus for Vikram in two combative roles in the same movie.

Cinematographers Santosh Sivan and V. Manikandan have done a terrific job with some of the footage literally breathtaking: the collapsing bridge, rivals hanging literally to the bridge in adverse weather and a romantic ambience showing love-birds about to sit down for wine and dinner while overlooking soothing waters.

To another journo query, Abhishek responded, “I feel the audience will question themselves after this film. I think whenever I saw the rushes or when dubbing the film or even while performing, I think Mani as a director, was asking the audience, “what is right, what is wrong and who is to decide? What is right for Beera in the film is completely wrong for Dev. Who is to decide that Dev is right and Beera is wrong? What is right and what is wrong and who are we to judge?”

Talking of their relationship as a "married couple" a question arose about their credibility and chemistry on screen specially since in Raavan, the roles are adversarial. Aishwarya responded: “We all work together as a team to commit and to deliver. We are creating cinema. At that point, its not about personal equations, or what kind of relationship you share outside the set. We are all actors, we are all committed to the craft. That’s what it is all about. Abhishek joked, “I am not chasing her in the film, I have already kidnapped her.”

On differences between Hindi and Tamil versions, Ratnam said, “the idea was to make people see both versions and compare…essentially the same film but I do not believe in imposing that this is how a scene should be done, in terms of content and spirit, its the same.” Which has indeed come through in both the versions.

Its not a straightforward story of good triumphing over evil, there are wheels within wheels, and one needs to really think as to what is happening in today’s world – the dances and the costumes (Sabyas Achi) and the music (A.R. Rahman) notwithstanding. Some of the scenes where gruesomely symbolic (cutting off a coward’s hand) or shooting a defenseless man point blank. One wondered who was the torturer: the tribal or the cop?
_____________________________

[Raj S. Rangarajan is a New York based freelance writer. He covers trend stories on art, reviews books and films for media based in New York; Toronto, Canada; Seoul, Republic of Korea; and India. He can be reached at raj.rangarajan@gmail.com]

Friday, May 14, 2010

Desiclub.com Exclusive: Hrithik Roshan and Barbara Mori Interviews, May 14, 2010




Ultimate Bollywood » Bollywood Features » 2010

Kites, a Tribute to Honesty and Love: “Feel the Breeze on Your Face” says Hrithik. Throughout (shooting of) Kites, my dad has never been on the sets - Hrithik Roshan

Desiclub.com spoke with lead actors of Kites. For a 36-year-old, Hrithik Roshan, had a lot of "philosophical takes" on being an actor. Articulate, candid and serious-minded he reiterated his conviction that one should be honest to oneself in one's craft.

Barbara Mori worked as a model before studying acting at El Centro de Estudios de Formación Actoral, Mexico. Her acting debut was in the telenovela, "Al Norte del Corazón".? While there was initial speculation in the press and on blogs that Barbara didn't speak English, she turned out to be quite fluent.

Here is what they said:

Desiclub.com: Kites, being a different kind of film, how did you approach the script?
Hrithik: I had some unlearning to do. Training my mind to switch off - to let go; in my past films, I have done a lot of work where I knew was right - the right chord to hit and the reaction that it would evoke. There was this whole circle of this craft that was going off, but, sporadically in the middle, somewhere in Koi Mil Gaya and in Laksh I touched upon another area to this art.
I truly ventured out and enjoyed the flight of an actor, where there was no mind and I was creating something for the moment. I came out and didn't know what I had done because I had not planned that. It was something that came out of my mind spontaneously. And, I loved that. I said (to myself), what is that? There is something more to this art than earlier. All the work that I did, I kept being attracted to that, tried to relive that. Over time, I think, I was preparing myself to finally being ready for a film like Kites, where I had to completely just let go. Perform from the heart.
(Director of Kites), Anurag Basu's vision was demanding that. He wanted it to be a completely honest film, he did not want to see a star in it. He didn't want to see dialogues said perfectly. I just knew then that there was a destiny to this film.
Referring to his female lead, Barbara Mori, Hrithik added, "Then we had someone like her who entered our team, who provided the right kind of push and impetus toward the right direction, because she comes from the same school of thought. She's a very honest person. Whatever you create is only a reflection of the person you are inside. Her films have all been honest and convincing, the person she truly is.

Desiclub.com: How difficult was it for you to work with your dad?
Hrithik: Difficult? It wasn't difficult at all. In fact, I have been quite comfortable. My dad and I have a system in place, where we work without any egos. I can tell him anything that comes to my mind, about camera placement, about my lines and we connect as professionals. Either he convinces me or I convince him. We are both tied into equal loads of passion.
When we asked his dad, Rakesh Roshan the same question, Rakesh responded, "Not difficult at all. He's one person who just listens to the director. We call him at 6 a.m. and he'll show up on time. Also, he does one film at a time so his inputs are very valuable. He is constantly thinking of the film, and while we are thinking of other aspects he is focused on his job, getting prepared for his "character." He gives us a chance to improvise with the director.

Desiclub.com: You work very closely with your father. Coming from our Indian way of life, how did you manage the love scene with your dad watching?
Hrithik: As easy or as difficult as jumping off a 50-storey building. Barbara intercepted: he wasn't watching, he was not on the set. Throughout (shooting of) Kites, my dad has never been on the sets. He did not want to influence Anurag's vision. The only scenes he was present for were the action sequences, and even there he was like an assistant director running around to make sure that Anurag had whatever he needs. If Anurag wants a chopper, he had to make an urgent call to make a chopper happen. Because Anurag is so forgetful. He'll come to the set, and then he'll say, "wait a minute, I need a helicopter." My dad is like, "How the hell am I going to get a helicopter, we have this location for one day?" He was a father to all of us. He just made the children make the film, and he was supervising, he was there for all of us.

Desiclub.com: When playing a developmentally-disabled young man in Koi Mil Gaya weren't you taking a risk with your career since you are perceived as a dynamic action hero?
Hrithik: There's a lot of mental conditioning that my industry succumbs to - here its all about trying to fit into the mould, as to who eventually becomes a hero. Its all evolving; slowly we have transcended this and we are becoming more real. Films are about a slice of life, its something you need to identify with and live a journey that will inspire you and help you vent your emotions in your own life. I have been a movie star but it's a consequence of being an honest actor. What came first, the chicken or the egg? You'll never know.
I have been taking risks, which appear as risks from somebody else's perspective, but its not a risk for me because I have my passion there. For Koi Mil Kaya I was passionate about it, and I knew that. How can this be a risk? It's a risk if I am afraid but I was completely convinced about Koi Mil Haya.

Desiclub.com: How do you manage to stay so honest to yourself, so grounded?
Hrithik: I think I have become aware of my journey. We have to come to terms with one's perspective of the world, and finally realize that we are all basically the same, you and I are the same - all of us here are the same - basically at the core of things, we just have these little walls built around us that we need to build so that we feel protected. We are in our little boxes trying to connect with the walls afraid to show each other what we are truly about.
So, from God's point of view, we look pretty stupid. We are in boxes, all the time, still trying to show our good side, and hide the other aspects, which are part of all of us. I think that's a thought that grounds me. I am not a star - I am me - and you are you - and we are the same, there's no reason to feel fear. I have lost the need to rely on my own judgment of other people, everyone has their own point of view, and that is the truth, so all's well.

Desiclub.com: What do you expect out of Kites?
Hrithik: My 2-1/2 years of effort and my heart, it's a different kind of film, its something I am very proud of. I can promise you that it's a good picture and I hope you'll come to watch.

Desiclub.com: After all that you have done, do you feel you have finally reached your goals in Kites?
Hrithik: Yes, that's what life is about. In my earlier years, I was looking at a Finish Line. It was a race for me and there is a dog behind me, coming at me, and I am running and he is gonna get me - and I have to reach that Finish Line or he's going to bite, and I have to reach my goal; that's how I was working before. I had to get there, there was fear, there was anxiety, and all that. Now when I work, I realize, there is no Finish Line, there is no dog and I am running because I like the breeze on my face.
We are always trying to get somewhere, and if we feel fear that if we don't, somebody will pull us down and life will attack you and you'll fail and you'll lose. Life is not about that. There are no bad experiences. Everything is good if you can just enjoy the breeze on your face, no matter what.

Desiclub.com: Would you say Kites is a Bollywood movie?
Hrithik: No, it's not fair to put labels on any kind of creative work. I don't think Kites is a Bollywood love story, it's a human love story. A film about human beings, that's supposed to touch your heart - a film that is honest and made from the heart. Whether from China or Hollywood or Bollywood, it will find its audience. It could be identifiable on an international platform. The Indian version is being distributed all over the globe. The U.S. release has Brett Ratner's interpretation that will cater to a select western audience.

Desiclub.com to Barbara Mori: How did you prepare for this role?
Barbara: I read the script, saw a bit of the movie shooting, took salsa classes in Mexico for the movie, went to New Mexico on rehearsals, discovering things about car chases.

Desiclub.com: How did you get to talk in English?
Hrithik answered for her. It was basically a translation of the English that Anurag had written, so Barbara gave it heart. She just interpreted it in the right way. She was basically the writer of all her lines.

Desiclub.com: Is acting in different languages different?
Hrithik answered again: It definitely changes things in that when I speak in Hindi and in English, there is a shift in stance. For her it must have been more than that, she was acting the entire film in English, which is not her first language.
Barbara added, Of course, its a bit different. Acting in your language and being directed in another language. For instance Anurag speaks English, but he sounded like he was speaking in Hindi, because he speaks so fast. Too many times I said, Anurag "I am not Indian, speak in English, and he would say, "I am speaking in English"." It was a bit difficult initially but once I applied myself it became easy. I went to New Mexico, and started shooting and was scared. But soon realized the fears are in my mind.

Desiclub.com: This was your first Hindi film. What made you decide to work in this film?
Barbara: Well the script, the story. I read the script and I was touched by the story, beautiful love story between two human beings who fall in love even if they don't speak the same language, and I found that beautiful. It touched my heart and I said, I want to be part of this. True love and honest.

Desiclub.com: How different is it from the kind of work you have been doing?
Barbara: Its completely different. Its my first English movie, my first action movie, my first Bollywood movie and big budget movie. So, there's a lot of difference between this movie and what I have done before. But, I think, they will love it, because, in Mexico, we love all this action also. Kites has this bit of everything, humor, we also love stories, drama and laughter and everyone will feel like they want to fall in love again. Because love is universal.

[Raj S. Rangarajan is a New York based independent writer. He covers trend stories on art, reviews books and films for media based in New York; Toronto, Canada; Seoul, Republic of Korea; and India. He can be reached at raj.rangarajan@gmail.com]

Desiclub.com Exclusive: The Director and the Father, Rakesh Roshan, May 14, 2010






Ultimate Bollywood » Bollywood Features » 2010
Music is an efficient part of our movies, and it brings lot of money to the producer - Anurag Basu

by Raj S. Rangarajan

Continuing our series on Kites (Hindi) and its just-released Hollywood version - Kites, The Remix - Producer of the movie, Rakesh Roshan, Director Anurag Basu and Rajesh Roshan, Music Director tell us why they made the film.

Desiclub.com: How come you didn't direct Kites?
Rakesh: So happened I saw Anurag's Gangster and loved his work. He is one youngster who knows what filmmaking is all about. I told him, "I would like Hrithik to work with you in your next project." His response, "I make only small films, so for Hrithik I'd need to make a large film with a large canvas." Once I narrated the storyline Anurag was hooked and agreed to direct. I don't have to achieve anything; we have to make a good film, whoever directs is not important. I liked the way he worked.
In India, mostly, we give breaks to new actors or actresses, but we never think of giving a break to a new talented director. In those days movies were 5 crores of rupees, nowadays movies are more than 20 crores to make. We have to suppress our ego and give the project to somebody else, its not an easy thing. Once the script and vision were embedded in his mind he (Anurag) went along. I know what a filmmaker requires. I gave them the best location, best shooting facility, I should not deprive him of anything. I said, I am behind you like a rock. Don't worry about time and money, just spend money as need at the right place.

Desiclub.com: Your father was also in films and so is your son. All fathers have faith in their children, but at what stage did you decide that Hrithik, the actor is ready to become Hrithik, the star?
Rakesh: Well, when we are at home, we are having breakfast and lunch, together at the same table, we are father and son, we discuss so many things, but the moment we are at the set, he is an actor for me. There I don't see him as a son.
I have worked with Shahrukh (Khan), Salman (Khan), Anil (Kapoor), they are very good, we understand each other very well. Right from the word "Script", he (Hrithik) is there - he is in the place of the character.

Desiclub.com: Why an International version?
Rakesh: Because we wanted to be the first to go global. China and Korea have made International versions, India is lagging behind. After Kaho Naa.. Pyaar Hai, (where Hrithik debuted in 2000) and Koi Mil Gaya and 15 films (as director), its time specially since we have an Indian diaspora. I had to keep the Indian audience, cannot make a movie just for the foreign audience. Once we are successful, a time will come when we have to make just one version.

Desiclub.com: How difficult was it to shoot in Nevada? Are permissions easy to obtain?
Rakesh: I went and saw the location, and it took 2 months to obtain permissions. To a question on whether it was a meaningful experience to shoot in Mexico, Rakesh said, "it all depends on the script since the scripts demands what kind of location to choose. For instance I went to New Zealand for the first time to shoot for Kaho Naa.. Pyaar Hai and, for Koyi Mil Gaya, to Singapore. Some scenes were shot in English for Kites and some for the Hindi version. I felt only a love story would appeal to a global market and I wouldn't mind if one day my grandchildren entered the film industry."

Desiclub.com: Do you think music and melody has changed?
Rajesh Roshan, music director for the film, who was present, defended the concept that "we have all grown with the times, and have become more westernised, but that doesn't mean we have lost our tradition and soul. For instance, Rahman's music has scored very high marks for Slumdog; melody in Indian films and music has surpassed its limit, and will continue to survive. On the music aspect, Rajesh Roshan, Rakesh's brother explained how the sound track was original in that the beat had to be individually synchronized."
Expanding on their family unit, Rakesh added, "In our family as brothers we are very cohesive." In an interesting take on how film makers nowadays come to Rajesh Roshan with a pre-recorded tape of a western tune, and ask him to work on a similar melody for their film, Rajesh said, it was degrading for a music director. Rakesh calls his brother, the king of melody.

Rajesh ads, "It is not like a Bollywood film in that we had to add some extra scenes for the Hindi filmgoer to understand. We just went with our instincts since the songs are mostly in the background. Background scores in both versions are different. The mixing was done in Los Angeles and the background score for the English version was done by New Zealander, Graeme Revell, a film music composer.

Anurag declares: A film becomes big or small with ideas not with a large budget.

Desiclub.com: It was a huge budget film, what was the challenge?
Anurag: Making smaller films are more difficult because of shoestring budgets. Here, it was easy, had a free hand, and all I had to do was write. When asked about the budget, Rakeshji just said, "don't think of the film, you just write the script."

Desiclub.com: How you feel about the International cut? Do you have any inputs at all?
Anurag: All the songs in Kites are taking the story ahead, they are background songs, and it wasn't difficult to replace the score and have a fresh background score for the English version. When we write screenplay for Indian movies, we structure it differently. We plan for pre-interval, then for 15 minutes you are disconnected with the movie and then you start again. So, it has to be edited differently for the English version - something with Hollywood sensibilities.
For the International version, its the same film, but some sequences have been cut differently, and we have about 4 or 5 songs in the Hindi version, but all in the background. The international version has no songs and no dancing, but is expected be "racier, edgier and spunkier" than the Hindi edit. The English version was edited by Brett Ratner (using a remix formula originated by the international Kung Faux television series).

Desiclub.com: Brett Ratner is responsible for the International version. Now, looking at the International version, do you feel its like your film?
Anurag: Yes, its my film, most of the edits are mine, but, yes, in some places the background music could have been different?its very subjective?in some places I didn't like the background in the English version.

Desiclub.com: Was it a love story with action or an action story with love?
Anurag: I will not use action at all in the genre description, it's a love story all over. Who's betraying whom is the interesting aspect? Kites is written as a metaphor of the film. It took 30 days to write the script and it was easier in this case since the flow was fast. While writing I thought, kites fly high against and not with the wind - higher the wind, higher the flight - I normally use a metaphor when writing, and its interesting -- the more the obstacles the couple faced, their love became stronger. They fly all over, they come together, and they separate again like kites normally do but somehow their destiny is not in their hands. The title also starts with a 'K', sort of played conveniently into Rakesh Roshan's practice that all his films start with the letter 'K'.

Desiclub.com: Working with Hrithik what did he bring as an actor and how did you direct him?
Anurag: In fact, now with any story, any character I can see Hrithik in it. He is such a versatile actor. Initially I was apprehensive working with a big star, I used to avoid it - as an independent film maker, but Hrithik is a complete team-man, he knows his medium very well, he has a bit of director, a bit of a cameraman, editor, everything in him, he has a film-brain, all of which helps. All of this helped me as a filmmaker.
Hrithik was honest and organic. Barbara complained that I was messy. Our Bollywood acting comes over the top and loud sometimes, but this movie was real and unorganic. So, when you are working with a superstar, normally you see only the superstar, not the character. In Hrithik's case, all you see is the character, not the superstar.

Desiclub.com: Should Indian cinema go global?
Anurag: Why not, everything in India is becoming global, why not Indian cinema as well? Take China and Korea, we make ten times more movies than them but they make ten times more money since their audiences are global. I feel we are concentrating too much on the domestic market. Its an exciting time for Indian cinema?all of us young directors think that we have become global, but we are far from being global. Our audiences are just NRIs now who live here.

Desiclub.com: Is there a reluctance on the part of the global audience to look down on Bollywood for instance, Luck By Chance and Rock On? Do you think Kites will help that perception?
Anurag: They were good movies and we have to continuously churn out such movies to help our image. When they talk of Bollywood directors, they only think of Mira Nair, Shekhar Kapur, they have only two names; they don't know me, Karan Johar, Sanjay Leela Bhansali. We are too busy making movies for our own market in India, and we all want to cater to larger audiences. But, a different kind of marketing is needed to reach the large audience that would enjoy a Luck by Chance or a Rock On.

Desiclub.com: What next for Anurag Basu?
Anurag: Working on one, no title yet but with Ranbir and a new girl. It's a love story and a mixed genre, interesting character and story, have a metaphor too, you are up there as a film maker, but everyone is waiting and watching to see how Kites will perform at the Box office. A film becomes big or small with ideas not with a large budget.
Music is an efficient part of our movies. And, it brings lot of money to the producer, and also it has to be used differently every time. I love watching the dances and all the sequences including MTV but when I go on the floor to shoot I find it difficult to shoot the dance sequence. Its perhaps my drawback.
In Bollywood, you record the song, and then go for shooting. But for two sequences I didn't want to do that. I shot the sequences, and edited it but I had had a rough tempo in my mind. Rajesh Roshan suggested tempos too but it was tougher for him to compose, and we didn't have to edit or tweak too much. You can't make out that the song was done later.

Desiclub.com: Did you have to do lot of research since Barbara speaks only Spanish?
Anurag: Barbara herself did not speak much of English, now she's speaking good English, now she's real. My job in the film is a little overrated because I just captured her onscreen chemistry in the best possible way. They were amazing on the screen, I just had to shoot it because it was all real, and happening. They were trying to communicate in spite of the difficulties. I didn't want to make it appear staged. So, I briefed them and they understood, and I shot the scene.

Desiclub.com: So, is the headline, Kites helps Barbara speak English?
Anurag said, Yes.

[Raj S. Rangarajan is a New York based independent writer. He covers trend stories on art, reviews books and films for media based in New York; Toronto, Canada; Seoul, Republic of Korea; and India. He can be reached at raj.rangarajan@gmail.com]